Sorry for the long wait, but I’ve been sick. And I had to think REALLY HARD about your question.
First, let’s answer the question: “do bailouts like the one for the Auto companies ever work?”
The answer appears to be: they always work, unless the government is bailing out a financial institution in which case they seem to always fail. At least that’s what’s happened with a series of bailouts from 1970 to 2001.
http://www.propublica.org/special/government-bailouts
Now, let’s ask ourselves: “why?”. My personal opinion is that people involved in “high finance” seem to be more interested in money than in doing the right thing. Money-oriented people are often characterized as being soulless, money-grubbing bastards that don’t even know what the right thing to do might be! Contrast this to people in the rail industry, automotive industry, aerospace industry, etc. that may make big and sometimes fatal mistakes, but who are more likely to “go down with the ship”. The bankers, frankly, always take care of themselves first.
I, of course, apologize to any of you who are bankers, are married to bankers and or are the progeny of bankers. And bear in mind that this is a broad generalization… but also realize that the higher a person gets in the financial system, the more likely they are to love money above all else. They tend to take the cash, make sure they’re “okay” (i.e. rich beyond belief) and then let their company tank because it’s not worth the effort and with all that money they can go do it again somewhere.
The fact that so much of the bailout money is going and has gone to financial institutions is therefore worrisome. Bailing out banks will NOT solve the problem. What it WILL do is maybe make some people believe that the government is doing something and therefore distract them for awhile so that the real solution can get some traction. I think that the higher-ups in government know that the banking things are a diversion so that they can get the public works program up and running properly.
One little tidbit that shows me the banks don’t care: the get a bailout and then turn around and INCREASE interest rates, further damaging over-extended small people.
I do believe that spending Federal money on infrastructure is a VERY good idea. Have you driven on an American road lately? They are sorely maintained and this money won’t be wasted. Since it goes to the Average Joe in the form of wages, it’s a good thing. My fear is that the public works program is NOT BIG ENOUGH. More on that in a moment.
Now, just how big IS the bailout and stimulus package? Well… if you really want to be scared, do a google search for “total bailout cost” or “total bailout cost Faber”. Here’s one of the links that’s high on the list:
http://news.kontentkonsult.com/2009/01/ … -wars.html
As you can tell from the URL, the bailout cost now exceeds the cost of all American wars (after adjusting the war costs for inflation, of course).
8.7 Trillion dollars is now being bandied about. A bit of math:
A dollar bill is 0.0043 inches thick.
A pile of 8,700,000,000,000 dollar bills is therefore 37,410,000,000 inches high.
That would be 3,117,500,000 feet
Which is 590,436 miles.
The moon is about 240,000 miles from earth…
Okay, how about this: let’s say the bailout is only $4 Trillion.
If you could get 5% interest on a deposit that size, you’d earn $200 billion per year.
Which is $547,945,205 per day — and that’s just INTEREST
Which is $22,831,050 per hour, or $6,342 per second!
Okay, so maybe you want to keep the money and put it under your mattress because you don’t trust banks (which is wise). If you spend $1,000,000 each and every day (and get NO INTEREST) then the $4 Trillion would last you some 4 million days.
Which is 10,959 years.
This post is getting long, so I’m going to stop for awhile. Stay tuned, though.